Leading epidemiology experts have called for harsh mask rules to be scrapped, claiming there is not enough community transmission to justify their use.
Leading epidemiology experts have called for harsh mask rules to be scrapped, claiming there is not enough community transmission to justify their use.

Expert says masks ‘not worth it’ for Greater Brisbane

Masks should not be mandatory in Greater Brisbane after Friday unless social distancing is impossible, say leading academics.

Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk has stopped short of declaring masks would no longer be mandatory from Friday (1 am) when other restrictions are set to ease, but epidemiologists want to see the rule scrapped while there is no community transmission.

Greater Brisbane residents were forced into a 72-hour lockdown on January 8 and masks were mandatory in public, even when travelling alone in a car.

The restrictions were eased on January 11 with face masks still mandatory within most indoor places.

The clampdown came after a cleaner at a hotel used to quarantine international travellers tested positive for the more contagious UK variant of the virus, but other than the cleaner's partner also testing positive, there has been no community transmission of the strain.

Ms Palaszczuk is expected to announce masks will no longer be mandatory on Thursday, other than at airports, upon the advice of Queensland's chief health officer Dr Jeanette Young.

Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk will announce an easing of restrictions for Greater Brisbane residents on Friday. Picture: NCA NewsWire / Dan Peled
Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk will announce an easing of restrictions for Greater Brisbane residents on Friday. Picture: NCA NewsWire / Dan Peled

Peter Collignon, a professor of infectious diseases at ANU, argued the "value" of masks when community transmission is extremely low or not occurring is not worth the "inconvenience" of wearing them.

"Whenever you have a lot of COVID transmission, or you're not sure how much there is, they are worthwhile," Mr Collignon said.

"If there has been no transmission and no evidence to suggest it, then the value of masks becomes very marginal … the value of masks is not all that great compared to the inconvenience.

"If you are in Sydney, Brisbane or Melbourne, where there is minimal or no transmission, there is not much value in masks and I'm loathe to say they should be compulsory."

Australian National University Professor of Infectious Diseases Peter Collignon says he is loathe to suggest mask should be mandatory when community transmission is low. Picture: Supplied
Australian National University Professor of Infectious Diseases Peter Collignon says he is loathe to suggest mask should be mandatory when community transmission is low. Picture: Supplied

He said they may be of use where people are unable to social distance, such as on crowded public transport, although you're more likely to catch the virus in your own home than anywhere else.

"There may be an argument for public transport," he said.

"But most of the transmission occurs in the home, so perversely, that's where I would wear a mask, inside your own home."

Griffith University Professor Nigel McMillan says it would still be useful for people to carry masks for occasions when they cannot social distance. Pictured: Supplied
Griffith University Professor Nigel McMillan says it would still be useful for people to carry masks for occasions when they cannot social distance. Pictured: Supplied

Griffith University Infectious Diseases & Immunology director Nigel McMillan suggested masks be worn only within venues or in places where social distancing cannot be maintained.

"No, we don't have to (wear masks), but it's a good idea to keep one on you for when you can't avoid crowds," he said.

"Ultimately, it is up to the individual."

Originally published as Expert says masks 'not worth it' for Greater Brisbane


Bushfire season ends early after rain, mild conditions

Premium Content Bushfire season ends early after rain, mild conditions

RFS ends bushfire warning period after rain covered the region

'HARD TIMES': How Rex decision will affect local businesses

Premium Content 'HARD TIMES': How Rex decision will affect local businesses

Growing concern about Rex's plan to cut flights to Lismore

Staggering amount Aussie Airbnbs rake in

Staggering amount Aussie Airbnbs rake in

Survey reveals Aussie women leading the world as Airbnb hosts